Identity Crisis? Identity Resolution?

— by

Hello mathematicians, puzzlers, and other curious people!

Whilst doing homework for my numerical methods class (which is about getting computers to do math for you), and using GeoGebra to troubleshoot a result that wasn’t working out, I ran into an issue: GeoGebra’s expression for a derivative was different from what I had calculated by hand. It had some terms the same and some different. With a little rearrangement, where I had (x-1) \sec^2 x, it had x \tan^2 x - tan^2 x + x - 1.

So, I graphed both:

A picture is not a proof, but I’m pretty sure we could make a “they’re the same picture” meme out of this.

Next time I teach trig identities, I think I’ll present (x-1) \sec^2 x = x \tan^2 x - tan^2 x + x - 1 as a conjecture that needs verified, and see what happens.

Calc You Later!


Leave a Reply